top of page

Taking holiday orders now!

IMG_0267 (1).JPG

Taking holiday orders now!

69327461551__0FEABF7E-5C4E-497F-8E5E-25AA4A3E7FB7 (1).jpeg

WELCOME TO MARILYN


Our wares come from the winters we spent in Marilyn’s warm, heirloom-filled kitchen where trays cooled on every surface. We honor those memories in every small batch we make today.

IMG_1972.heic
IMG_6394 (1).JPG
69336476611__52B9C7FB-68DE-404F-A020-8180E3518D5D.HEIC
IMG_9685 2_edited.jpg

TAKING HOLIDAY

ORDERS NOW!

Screenshot 2025-11-18 at 4.21.28 PM.png

Marilyn began in an Ohio home where winter pressed against the windows and the kitchen stayed warm –  a place crowded with family heirlooms, spice candles, and trays of cookies and pies cooling on every surface.

 

We grew up in that room, watching Marilyn move through the clutter with quiet rhythm, shaping dough, lifting trays from the oven, filling the space with a sweetness that felt like its own kind of language. Though perfection was never the goal, she somehow managed to make even the imperfect perfect  Everything she made felt personal and that's what we want to bring to you.

 

Those winters taught us that food carries memory, and that lesson shaped Lost in the Sauce and this small bakery named in her honor. Every cookie we make now carries a trace of that kitchen. A reminder of where we come from and what we hope to return to.

OUR STORY

981CC7CC-2EEC-409B-B41D-1368A40A2A27 (1).JPG

RECIPIES FROM MARILYN'S KITCHEN

Discover our handmade cookies and treats, shaped from the traditions we learned in Marilyn’s kitchen. From classic cutouts to winter staples, each treat reflects the quiet rituals that defined our holidays.

We deliver locally 10-15 miles in Los Angeles!

And we ship nationwide!

Get all of your holiday orders in by December 15th to ensure a December 23rd delivery! 

Marilyn's Classic Cut Outs

The classic offering. You can't go wrong.

Marilyn’s classic cutouts come from her family’s secret recipe, the one she baked every winter in her Ohio kitchen. Each cookie is hand shaped and available in designs for any occasion including holidays, birthdays, graduations, and special celebrations. These are the cookies we grew up with, made in small batches and decorated with the same steady touch Marilyn taught us.

new-anise-pizzelle-1200-square-500x375.jpg

Italian Holiday Staples

Let us bring those special Italian treats to your table. 

Pizzelles, ricotta cookies, and other holiday staples are baked by hand using the traditions we grew up with. These cookies carry the familiar flavors and rituals of a season spent around a warm kitchen table.

Custom Orders

We're only limited by imagination!

If you need something special, we are happy to create it. From pies to macaroons to custom cookies, we can bring a little of Marilyn’s warmth to your celebration. Reach out to us with your ideas and we will work with you to bake something you can't find anywhere else!

bottom of page